Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning and Aaron Rodgers, the elite of the elite, these are the guys every other quarterbacks are compared to. They are unquestionably some of the greatest of all-time, so we ask, which one of them is the king of the hill, who is the best of the best?
This is a debate that we here at the A-List can’t seem to resolve, there seem to be too many criteria to consider when trying to rank a QB. Everyone seems to be hung up on every little thing: championships (they’ve all won at least one), individual awards (again they are all well decorated and Manning is the NFL’s only four time MVP), stats, football IQ and popularity (no one is better than this four when it comes to this three departments).
So why I do not disagree with the above yardstick to rate QB, I believe every athlete should be rated based on raw talent, a player’s ability to play their position, and ability to make teammates better and raise their game.
So let’s not concentrate on all those criteria, let’s focus on the talent. Which of this four is the most talented quarterback?
Cast your vote below: